Which is the Best Print Method for Custom Printing Baseball Shirts?

Choosing the right print method is crucial to ensure the final product looks great and lasts long. Each print method offers unique advantages and is suited to different types of designs and materials. Whether you’re looking for vibrant, full-color prints, durable and textured logos, or cost-effective solutions for large orders, understanding the various printing techniques can help you make an informed decision. 

In this article, we’ll dive into various printing methods, such as screen printing, direct-to-garment (DTG) printing, and heat transfer. Each comes with its own set of benefits and ideal use cases. Let’s explore which method will work best for your custom baseball shirts! To purchase custom baseball shirts with high quality printing, please visit this page to learn more!

custom baseball jerseys styles

Print Methods for Custom Baseball Shirts

1. Screen Printing

Ideal for large orders and team uniforms

  • Vibrant, Long-Lasting Colors: Screen printing uses thick layers of ink to produce rich, durable colors that stand up well to repeated washing and wearing. This method ensures that your team’s logo and colors remain bright and bold throughout the season.
  • Cost-Effective for Bulk Orders: This method is highly economical for large quantities because the setup cost is spread over a larger number of shirts. It’s perfect for outfitting an entire team or for promotional events where you need many shirts.
  • Versatile Fabric Compatibility: Screen printing works well on various fabrics, including cotton, polyester, and blends. This versatility means you can choose the best material for comfort and performance without worrying about the print quality.

2. Heat Transfer Printing

Great for custom numbers and names on jerseys

  • Suitable for Small Quantities and One-Off Designs: Heat transfer printing is ideal for adding personalized names and numbers to jerseys without needing to produce large print runs. This flexibility makes it perfect for small teams or individual players.
  • Relatively Affordable: This method is budget-friendly, especially for smaller orders or unique, custom designs. It doesn’t require the extensive setup of screen printing, making it a cost-effective choice for limited runs.
  • Works Well on Various Fabrics: Heat transfer printing can be used on a wide range of fabrics, including cotton, polyester, and blends. This adaptability allows for consistent results across different types of apparel.

3. Direct-to-Garment (DTG) Printing

Excellent for complex designs and gradients

  • Best for Small Team Orders with Intricate Graphics: DTG printing excels at producing detailed, high-quality images directly onto the fabric. It’s ideal for designs with fine details, gradients, and multiple colors that require precision.
  • Provides High-Quality Prints: This method delivers superior print quality with vibrant colors and precise details, closely resembling the original artwork. The prints are smooth and integrated into the fabric, offering a softer feel.
  • Ideal for Cotton and Cotton Blends: DTG printing works best on cotton and cotton-blend fabrics. These materials absorb the ink well, ensuring vibrant and durable prints that feel comfortable against the skin.

4. Sublimation Printing

Produces high-quality, vivid prints that last a lifetime

  • Best for Polyester Fabrics: Sublimation printing is designed for use on polyester fabrics and requires a minimum of 40% polyester content. This method infuses the ink into the fabric fibers, creating a permanent and vibrant image.
  • Allows for Full-Color, Edge-to-Edge Designs: This technique enables full-coverage designs with no limits on color or complexity. It’s perfect for creating jerseys with intricate patterns, logos, and graphics that cover the entire shirt.
  • Highly Durable: Although more expensive, sublimation prints are exceptionally durable. The colors won’t fade, crack, or peel over time, even with frequent washing and exposure to the elements. This longevity makes it a worthwhile investment for high-quality, long-lasting team apparel.

Making the Right Choice

Choosing the best print method depends on your specific needs:

  • Screen Printing is ideal for large orders with bold designs and consistent colors.
  • Heat Transfer Printing is perfect for personalized, small quantity orders.
  • Direct-to-Garment Printing excels in producing high-detail, complex graphics for small team orders.
  • Sublimation Printing offers the most durable and vivid prints, ideal for all-over designs on polyester fabrics.

Where to Print Your Custom Baseball Shirts for Your Team?

Best Sites to Order Custom Baseball Shirts

1. Team Sportswear

TeamSportswear.com makes it incredibly easy to customize and order your baseball uniforms online. You can use their design tool or upload your existing baseball logo to the jerseys. This site allows you to customize almost every element of your uniform, from choosing the products to selecting the best printing method for your team’s logo. Beyond the typical full-button jersey, you can add your logo to a wide variety of garments, including pants, caps, raglan tees, and other accessories.

TIP: Browse by color, brand, or product to find exactly what you need. Uploading your baseball logo is simple. After selecting a product and printing method, choose “Add Images” to upload your own image file.

Team Sportswear

Team Sportswear1

2. Custom Ink

CustomInk.com is known for its user-friendly customization page and high-quality products. There’s no minimum order required, so you can print just one jersey or enough for the entire team. You can also choose names and numbers for each jersey, which is incredibly handy. I recommend screen printing for names and numbers as it offers better durability.

NOTE: Uploading your baseball logo is easy. Just browse from your computer and adjust it on the garment. CustomInk offers standard free shipping within the US, which takes about two weeks. They also have rush delivery (6-8 days) for an additional 10% of your order total, and super rush delivery (5 days) for an additional 25%.


3. The Graphic Edge

TheGraphicEdge.com allows you to build your team’s entire uniform from scratch in one place. You can customize jerseys, pants, raglans, caps, jackets, accessories, and more. They provide tons of products, sizes, colors, and printing options. You need to email or call them to send your logo for printing on the gear.

NOTE: They have a 12-piece minimum order. However, they’ll do between 6-11 pieces for an additional $5.00 per garment. Shipping is available inside the US or to an APO US Military address, with delivery times between 1-5 business days.


4. My Locker

MyLocker.net is straightforward and allows you to add your own design to templates to visualize before ordering. You can browse products by type and then narrow your search to just baseball jerseys. Upload your design, choose the garment colors, and get an immediate preview. If you don’t have a logo ready, use their preset templates.

NOTE: The option to upload your logo is only available for cotton-based garments like raglan t-shirts, pullovers, and hoodies, not polyester jerseys. Besides sports gear, you can customize other products like towels, drinkware, phone cases, and more, making it a one-stop shop for team merchandising.

My Locker1

5. LeelineCustom

custom baseballshirtsAt LeelineCustom.com, We stand out with its high-quality materials and advanced customization techniques.  We offer options like sublimation, screen printing, and embroidery, ensuring vibrant, durable designs. LeelineCustom provides personalized service, working closely with you to create a design that matches your vision. We also emphasize sustainability, offering eco-friendly fabrics and ethical production practices.

TIP: LeelineCustom offers free artist reviews to ensure your design looks professional. Their user-friendly online design tools make the customization process smooth and enjoyable.


Speaking of custom printing baseball shirts, several methods stand out: screen printing, heat transfer, direct-to-garment (DTG), and embroidery. Screen printing offers durability and vibrant colors, making it ideal for large orders. Heat transfer provides versatility for intricate designs, while DTG is perfect for detailed artwork and smaller batches. Embroidery, though less common for shirts, adds a premium touch.

Top sites to order custom baseball shirts include Custom Ink, Team Sportswear, and The Graphic Edge, LeelineCustom where you can find extensive customization options backed by robust customer services.

If you have custom clothing requests for your business, contact us with [email protected], and we’ll provide the right solutions.